I compared three Firewire preamps to use with Apple GarageBand; primarily for a single person's use rather than a band; therefore, I did not need a preamp with numerous inputs. I made a chart to help with quick comparison of features. Some friends helped with understanding terms and feature advantages. They are included on this page.

Many thanks to those who provided information and explanations, and to the sales rep at Presonus (see below). The info was very helpful in clarifying the features and specifications. You may want to bookmark this page to direct others with similar questions about preamps at this level.


Presonus Firebox
I chose this unit. It has the highest frequency response of the three preamps, although that was not the most significant factor. The email sales/tech support at Presonus is quick and helpful. The preamps are very high quality and 6 inputs can be recorded simultaneously. I would have liked for the unit to have a power on/off switch but I determined that it would not be a major factor for working with my system (G4-933Ghz Quicksilver 2002) and practices. The unit takes up very little desk space, easily portable, and has a metal casing. I also believe this will be compatible and be at a good quality level if I ever move on to software like Logic.

One feature I like a lot is with the FireBox Mixer software. I allows you to adjust the playback volume when recording so you can hear your recording louder than the playback.

As I write this the Edirol FA-66 has been released. It is getting good reviews. I suggest giving that serious consideration.

I wrote the following in an email to Presonus after my decision:

"What I thought was going to be a simple search and purchase for a Firewire preamp to record into Apple's GarageBand turned into extensive evaluation of many different factors and features. I narrowed it to three units, including the Presonus Firebox.

I wrote to your sales service with some questions. The first thing that impressed me was the quick response. Over the next few days we exchanged half a dozen emails and Presonus was quick to reply every time. As a comparison, I wrote another company two days ago and still have not received a reply (Update: I did a week later).

Your sales representative was informative, articulate, courteous, and patient. I am very appreciative of all of those attributes. He helped me understand specifications and how the Presonus product compared with other brands. He even gave me straightforward feedback on info I sent him regarding information I quoted from another manufacturer's website.

A reliable friend highly recommended Presonus; however, I needed a different model than he uses so I had to compare features carefully with other manufacturers. I now believe I will be purchasing a good product and the right product for me. The pre-sales service was definitely a deciding factor in my decision."

M-Audio Firewire 410
I have a MobilePre USB from this company that has performed well with GarageBand. I was interested in a firewire interface to take off the load that a USB preamp does on the CPU. I tend to record numerous tracks and like to use lots of effects.

The 410 is owned by more customers than the FireBox. It's popularity, reliability, and M-Audio's connection with Apple make it a safe choice. Although I don't record many tracks simultaneously, it only allows 4 while the other two brands allow 6. This unit has a power on/off switch that the Firebox does not have. The manual is very thorough and even their website provides important information not found on other sites (I asked Presonus about a couple of the FAQ's from M-Audio's site and they verified them; however, the info on the M-Audio site does leave out some details so it took both sources to understand issues, such as about hot-plugging concerns. Kudos to PreSonus again.)

The Firewire 410 does not have balanced inputs or outputs (even the MobilePre does!) except for the XLR connections, which is a standard. Email tech support usually takes a couple of days. I have not phoned them but have heard they are nice and are helpful.

Edirol FA-66
This was introduced in January 2005 and as of April 27th is still a pre-order product, if you can find a reliable retailer who sells it. Reviews by actual customers don't exist as of that date. The website did not have sales support, which made me suspect if I were to have problems in the future and portions of their website were still under construction. Great features, and probably is going to prove to be a good unit, but a purchase felt risky at this point.

Preamp Comparison Chart
FEATURE
Presonus FIREBOX M-Audio FIREWIRE 410 Edirol FA-66
Frequency Response
10Hz-50kHz 20-40kHz 20-40 @ 96kHz
20-22 @ 48kHz
20-20 @ 44.1kHz

Preamp Input Impedance

1.3 Ohms    
Instrument input impedance
1m Ohms    
Preamp THD
<0.0005% 0.00281%  
Preamp Gain
+60dB +66dB  
Line input impedance
10k Ohms    
TRS Output impedance
51 Ohms    
TRS Main Outputs
51 Ohms    
Headphone Output
150mW/ch
20Hz-20kHz
Separate driver steams allow mixing volume level of prerecorded output sound from software with current recording input sound level listening.
   
Phantom power
48v +/- 2v Global 48v Global (phantom switch affects all mic inputs) 48v Global
Bus power
6-pin FireWire 6 6 & 4
Power switch No Yes Yes
Analog to digital converters
24-bit (up to 96kHz) 24-bit 96kHz 6x6 24-bit 192kHz
4x4 24-bit 192kHz
ADC dynamic range
107dB 108dB  
Digital to Audio converters
24-bit (up to 96 kHz)    
DAC dynamic range
110dB 108dB  
Inputs
6 4 6 (44.1, 48, 96kHz
Stereo out 96kHz 192kHz  
Outputs
10 10 (8 analog) 6
Mic/instrument combo inputs
Yes Yes. Switch allows toggle between line inputs on the back of the unit and the mic/line input on the front, so you can keep four input devices plugged in. Yes
MIDI in/out?
Yes Yes Yes
MIDI connection type
Combo MIDI & S/PDIF jack (9-pin rectangular) Requires cable adapter. Normal Normal
S/PDIF
Yes (see above) Requires cable adapter. Optical (square jack)
& Coaxial (RCA shaped)
Yes, w/LED (RCA shaped?)
Latency
Zero w/ their software setting? Near zero. Actually may be a more accurate description of all units. Zero
Plug and play
Install control driver. Install control driver Driver installs automatically?
1/4" Balanced input/output
Yes/Yes no/no Yes/Yes (+4dB)
Analog limiter
No Attenuated Yes
XLR input level
Balanced balanced? -50 to -10dBu
balanced
Signal to noise ratio
  -107dB (typical, A-weighted) Output: 105
Input: 102
Operating level
  -10dB unbalanced  
OS requirement
10.3.7+ 10.2.6+  
RAM requirement (min/rec)
256/512 256/512  
CPU requirement (min/rec)
G4 800Mhz/Dual 1GHz G4 667Mhz  
Recording software included
Cubase LE (48 track capability) M-Audio  
Case
Metal Plastic? Metal

 

What is the advantage of different sample rates?
Edirol is the only unit that allows changing them and shows the highest number? Is that the best choice?

Visitor comments:

More accurate recording at higher sample rates at the expense of file Size and Bandwidth.

Resolution of sound. Like the difference between a 72dpi and 300dpi photo.

Higher is better, but you will not hear any difference between a 48khz and a 44.1khz on a CD since a CD is only limited to 44.1

Actually, they all allow you to choose a different sample rates.

Latency on the FireBox says, "zero with DSP mixer." What does that mean?
I meant, what does "zero with DSP mixer" mean? The other units say zero when monitoring from the preamp, but not via the software.
 
Visitor comments:

Latency means the delay between the time when the input is received, processed then output.

DSP = digital signal processor So a DSP Mixer is an onscreen digital mixer. So there is zero latency (delay) if you use a software mixer vs. a hardware mixer.

The DSP mixer in the Firebox routes the incoming signal directly to the monitor/headphone outputs, without a trip through the computer.

Phantom power on the Firewire 410 says, "Global." What does that mean? The others are 48v.
The Firewire 410 does have an on/off switch for Phantom Power.
 
Visitor comments:

Global probably means you can't turn Phantom Power off. It's always 48v.

Global means they have one switch for the phantom power on both mic preamps, instead of a switch on each mic input.

Firebox specifications say, "G5/G4 accelerated cards not supported." What does that mean? I upgraded my CPU on my G4, is that the same thing?
 
Visitor comments:
Probably the same thing meaning they may not offer support if they know you're using a third party card (GB does not support aftermarket cards either, btw)
The Firebox is the only one with specs on the headphone output. Is that important?
 
Visitor comments:

Only for extreme professionals with electrostatic headphones will tell any difference.

20hz to 20khz is pretty much universal. That's beyond most people's hearing range.

What are the ADC and DAC dynamic ranges?
Am I going to hear much difference between these models?
 
Visitor comments:

Analog to Digital Converter and Digital to Analog Converter. The range between the weakest audible signal and the strongest clean signal. A narrow dynamic range will result in clipping distortion (rasp or buzz) when you set the minimum signal up in clearly audible range. You have to compress the signal to pass it all cleanly. A wide dynamic range allows relatively uncompressed program material to pass without distortion.

No. They are so low these days.

Assuming they're using decent converters (and these are all decent, really), the dynamic range is determined by the bit depth. Since all of these can record and playback 24-bit audio, they'll all be about the same in dynamic range, and it exceeds the dynamic range of human hearing.

What is signal to noise ratio?
So, below -100 is going to be satisfactory?
 
Visitor comments:

With S/N ratio -100, it's so far down the only hiss you hear is from your power amp.

In analog and digital communications, signal-to-noise ratio, often written S/N or SNR, is a measure of signal strength relative to background noise. The ratio is usually measured in decibels (dB).

When there is no sound present, in many amps and other audio components, there is usually a bias or hiss. signal to noise ratio tells you how much of this hiss there is.

S/N only really counted in the past with transistor, tube amps and tape players. Digital has almost made it a non-issue.

The Firebox has a combo MIDI and S/PDIF jack. Is that a problem?
 
 

No, just means you need to use the provided adapter. It is a cost saver. One plug vs. 4 plugs. It is also a space saver on the box.

no, it's not a problem. It's a reasonable way for them to get around the limited amount of panel space on the back of the unit.

Firewire 410 is the only one showing Stereo out? Is that an important feature?
 
Visitor comments:

Yes, if you want to record to a cassette deck or some other stereo device.

non-issue. These all have several outputs, conversion of any pair to a stereo output would take a simple y-cable.

What is balanced and unbalanced input/output?
I received very technical answers. Some units have both, and my speaker monitors have both, but I do not understand how to use them.
 
Visitor comments:

Balanced signal uses a third conductor to deliver the bias current at a controlled level, and keep it separate from the grounded conductor. It reduces RF noise.

...basically, if you are running a chord over 25 feet, use balanced. Vice versa.

The wiring three-pin balanced connectors is designed to reduce noise and interference. You can use much longer cable lenghts from a balanced connector.

Bottom line, a balanced pair has better noise resistance, but it's not really critical on high-level signals, like the line level used to drive an amp or powered monitors. On microphones, balanced cables are normal, and quite important.

Should I be concerned about the XLR input level?
 
Visitor comments:
No. This is usually your professional mic input.
What is preamp gain?
Seems to be quite a range between the two listed. So the one with the higher number allows finer tuning of gain control?
 
Visitor comments:

Having a wide range of gain levels available allows use of a wide range of input devices. The ones you'll be most concerned with are mics and guitars.

How loud the preamp can output. It is nothing to worry about.

Pretty much.

What is analog limiter? Only Edirol shows it.
GarageBand has this capability with peak limiting (?) Probably not a concern, even though it could be a convenience on the preamp?
 
Visitor comments:

It's similar to compression. You set a high threshold and a high ratio, so all it does is clip off transient peaks (pops and thumps in the microphone for instance, or pick attack on trebly guitar) without compressing the overall sound in an audible way... If the interface has the dynamic range to carry the peaks, you might compress the signal downstream to make it fit your mix. If not, you may have to limit it before it hits the interface, or reduce the gain. If the limiter is built in, it's a nice feature.

If you have someone scream in the mic, the limiter will drop the volume level automatically so that it will not distort the recording.

I tend to stay away from these and try to keep the volumes at reasonable levels. You do not want to limit your dynamics.

The Edirol blurb suggests the limiter is valuable as a field tool, where your first take is all you'll get. It's for use in live situations, where you can't control everything that happens. In the studio, set a level that'll cover your dynamic range and avoid limiting.

How important is the frequency response?
So the range of the Firebox is not of significant advantage?
 
Visitor comments:

Human hearing spans from about 200hz to 20khz, when you're very young. You can feel things below 200, but not so much hear them. It's more important to get even reproduction across the audible spectrum than to reproduce above 20khz.

Not really. If you were to listen to a cymbol using both units, I doubt you would be able to identify which recorded what.

Why does the Firewire 410 say OS X core compatible but requires firmware to be installed? The others are plug and play with no System Preferences settings?
Actually, I found out they are all plug and play. I realized that the firmware allows control of the preamp settings that interact with the computer and software. Interesting, the Edirol says the software is automatically installed when you plug the unit into the computer.
Visitor comments:
Depends on how they setup the hardware and how it interacts with the computer.
Other comments:
 
Visitor comments:
Many of the stats you mention are for engineers. Most components today are way high and not to worry about. The only ones who would really care are professional sound engineers.